CHRISTIANS HAVE ALWAYS BEEN ADEPT AT REINFORCING THEIR OWN STEREOTYPES AND BECOMING THE EMBODIMENT OF THE LEFT WiNG MEDIA’S STRAW MEN. YESTERDAY’S TRUMP EVANGELICAL IS TODAYS “CHRISTIAN NATIONALIST”. THE “PRO- LIFE” MOVEMENT IS NOW BEING INVADED BY HATEFUL “MEAN BOYS” WHO WANT TO “PROSECUTE WOMEN” IN ORDER TO “ABOLISH ABORTION NOW”. MEANWHILE YESTERDAYS REALITY SHOW HOMESCHOOLING STARS ARE TODAY’S PEDOPHILE RING PRODUCING “RIGHT WING CONSERVATIVE ACTIVISTS”.
Rev Thomas Littleton
6/22/2023
HEADLINE – “Amazon Prime Video’s docuseries on Bill Gothard and the Duggar family has reportedly become the “biggest docuseries debut ever” for Prime Video.”
plural noun: stereotypes
- 1.a widely held but fixed and oversimplified image or idea of a particular type of person or thing.”the stereotype of the woman as the carer”
STEREOTYPES STRAWMEN AND FIVE EASY VILLAINS : NOT ALL HOMESCHOOLERS ARE “SHINY HAPPY” GOTHARDITES
This author’s family does homeschooling and have known thousands of homeschool families for over four decades. The self imploded Duggar celebrity homeschool family does not represent the typical homeschool family and NEVER HAS. The sort of morbid facination with a couple who gave birth to “19 Kids and Counting” has now become the head of the spear for vilifying all homeschooling families and Christian conservatism. Pause and think about this for a moment. Nineteen Children and being reality TV stars is not a typical family on ANY level. Yet the BROAD BRUSHING approach of “Shiny Happy People” docu-series makes it clear that the left wants to stop the homeschooling Christian movement in its tracks by pointing fingers at and further exploiting a troubled family whose parents knew as far back as 2003 that their son was molesting some of his sisters. It is well documented that the Duggars were warned by some very close to the parents and family NOT to hide the abuse. Agreed that the greater issue is that the parents did know – and others knew already YET they chose to move forward with making themselves celebrities and cashing in on reality TV . Again- far from typical family – and especially conservative homeschool family.
HOMESCHOOLING DUGGARS AND THE BILL GOTHARD CONNECTION.
This author was first exposed to Bill Gothard as a new believer in the late 1970s. Gothard’s approach to discipleship focused heavily on dating, marriage and family which struck this (then teen aged) author as “strange” given Gothard was single and had no children. Something did not gel yet when Gothard came to town his Institue in Biblical Life Principles ( IBLP )events were packed ..for a time.
(from the Amazon series “Shiny Happy People” story in Christian media.)
“The four-part series highlights how TLC’s reality show about the Duggar family, 19 Kids & Counting, became a popular hit but later fell from its status when allegations of physical and sexual abuse emerged.”
“Interviews in the docuseries reveal that the IBLP encouraged what many are calling physical and spiritual abuse.”
“Gothard resigned in 2014 from the IBLP after allegations of sexual abuse arose against him. Victims later filed a lawsuit but then voluntarily dismissed the lawsuit against him.”
So WHILE RIDING HIGH Gothard had multiple organizations and programs which are presented in the docu-series as producing disciples like the Duggar family. The films script portrays IBLP forming everything from The Joshua Generation- BREEDING AND TRAINING little CHRISTIAN NATIONALISTS who plan to “take over America” -to the future “stay at home moms” who are skilled in “MIDWIFERY”. NOW both the Duggars and Gothard have had their own troubles. Gothard is portrayed as an abuser of young women while at the same time the docu-series is rather obscure about which and what of the accusations made toward Gothard have been proven to be true. The BROAD BRUSH STOKES ARE STILL HITTING THE CANVAS in this portait of Christian Homeschooling and Christian Nationalism .
But REAL actual REALITY is that families living out their lives on TV for profit is neither normal nor healthy, nor is homeschooling the reason the scheme melted down, nor is THIS MODEL with 19 kids and counting the goal of many homeschooling families.
SHINY HAPPY STEREOTYPES REINFORCED FROM THE INSIDE
One of the most effective ways to ramp up the vilification and stereotyping of Christian homeschooling as the “breeding ground ” of pedophiles and “Christian Nationalist” is to use one of the well placed activist and political operatives like Christianity Today Editor and former Baptist leader Russell Moore to do the follow through.
Read carefully and watch a masterful shammer at work- Moore is so “disturbed by what he sees” and is all too happy to pick up the BROAD BRUSH of the left media and go to work.
“The Joshua Generation and the Paradox of Power“
“The Amazon Prime docuseriesShiny Happy People: Duggar Family Secrets explores the reality-television homeschooling family and the system that shaped them—Bill Gothard’s Institute in Basic Life Principles—along with the fundamentalist mindset behind it….”
“Much of what it discusses felt nauseatingly familiar given all that we’ve seen in the last several years. One phrase, however, particularly struck me: the Joshua Generation.
Such was the language used by some sectors of the homeschooling and other movements to indicate the “long game” of training up those who could restore national greatness and steer the country back to a “Christian America.” And as Alex Harris, who was interviewed in the series, points out, some aspects of this idea became a reality….”
( Keep in mind about the work of these “voices from within the church”
SHAMMER –
a person who makes deceitful pretensessynonyms:fake, faker, fraud, humbug, imposter, impostor, pretender, pseud, pseudo, role player, sham )
MOORE GOES ON TO SAY
“There’s nothing wrong with preparing students for places of influence in politics (or medicine or business), but the Christian nationalism mixed up in much of the Joshua Generation rhetoric betrays a bigger question: the nature of real power. It seems the Joshua Generation came from a generation that did not know Joshua….”
(NOTE Moore was raised in the Democrat Party political machine of the deep South and worked himself as a Democratic Congressional Staffer. Moore is likely troubled more about the brand of the party of politics he sees the Joshua types serving than the asserted harm to Christian faith . )
“One generation of American Christians offers up a vision of a Christian America, and the next makes it happen…”
Moore:”Note that in this analogy, the Promised Land is the United States of America and Joshua is the present generation. It’s no coincidence that the “Christian” rally days prior to the January 6 attack on the United States were called the “Jericho March”—echoing the account in the Book of Joshua in which the walls of Jericho city collapsed when the Israelites shouted and blew their trumpets (Josh. 6). God said to Joshua, “See, I have delivered Jericho into your hands, along with its king and its fighting men” (v. 2).”
MOORE REALLY MAKES HIS POINT :
“The series Shiny Happy People leaves us with yet one more example of how religion can be used for sexual predation on vulnerable people. The allegations there, some of which have been proven in court, are enraging and gut-wrenching. These cases demonstrate how power, which was said to be all about serving Jesus, was instead wielded for sadism. We are left wondering how people can rail against a decadent culture while using the words of Jesus to destroy lives—in actions so decadent even the secular culture would recoil…. True power is not placing interns on Capitol Hill or filling clerkships at the Supreme Court—especially not if what’s behind these efforts is a dead “Christianity” that trades the power of the gospel for the gospel of power.”
THE CHURCH REALITY SHOW CONSERVATIVE CHRISTIANS LIVE OUT EVERY SUNDAY
WILL THE REAL POLITICAL OPERATIVES PLEASE STAND UP AND TAKE A BOW?
PERHAPS THE NEXT REALITY SHOW COULD BE : “AMERICA’S INFLITRATED SEMINARIES 19,000 DISCIPLES AND COUNTING …”
Russell Moore was educated and served for decades under his mentor Albert Mohler at SBTS in Louisville KY and Dean and then Provost before becoming the Baptist chief “ethicist” as President of the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission (ERLC) .This trainwreck leadership lasted for 8 years -ending badly. Moore had spent 24 years helping educate a generation of “third ( mushy middle ) way” evangelical preachers who are often unaware that they have been bred into “political operatives” in the pulpits of America by mentors like Russell Moore, his mentor Albert Mohler, World Magazines Marvin Olasky and TGC’s Timothy Keller . These new type of pulpiteers have an entire “Theology of political engagement” which has been drafted to MOVE THE POLITICS OF THE CONSERVATIVE CHRISTIAN POPULATION in America into lockstep with the new growing Christian LEFT… all while thinking that they are being better at being Biblical and serving “Gospel Issues”.
So, if Bill Gothard and Homsechooling are villains producing “Christian Nationalist ” then what are these evangelcial educators who are working for the other side and flooding conservative seminaries, churches and pulpits with Critical Theories and Third Way Fabian Socialism ,The London School of Economics LSE ? Who then are the current sheep in Wolves clothing celebrated by the infamous London based institution LSE ? REALITY is even more intersting than a reality show isn’t it?
MOORE AND KELLER AND OTHERS LIKE THEM DO NOT WANT NATIONALISM OF ANY KIND BECAUSE THEY ARE COMMITTED TO “GLOBALISM” AND GLOBAL GOALS VISIONS.
Loving Well -For the Common Good- promoting Human Flourishing- Thinking Globally- Being known for what we are for not what we are against- Providing Community – and Community Development – and being Civil in our engagement of the culture – merging Faith and Science and right and left narratives into the mushy middle set to collapse into the left..these are the talking points and the END GAME of this monkey business .
WHERE THE ATTACK ON HOMESCHOOLING IS REALLY COMING FROM.
A BATTLE FOR OWNERSHIP …OF THE HEARTS AND MINDS OF CHILDREN
Concerns by the left about homeschooling are rooted in the fact that for the last 100 years plus in America the left has been seeking to OWN K-12 education.They DO OWN public schools from the Department of Education to the local school board to the local classroom. By doing so they are able to partner with Planned Parenthood/ SIECUS / Global GOALs /UNESCO and a host of other leftist organizations to fully indoctrinate children. Then to focus on accusing Conservative Christians who have fled the system and seek to disciple their children as Christians in Christian education as “problematic” is a pretty obvious solution to the growing “problem “of homeschooling.
An example of the Attack on Homeschooling :
“Harvard Law School professor Elizabeth Bartholet calls for a radical transformation in homeschooling.”
Law School professor says there is little legal oversight of educational standards or safeguards against abuse.”
“Nationally renowned child welfare expert Elizabeth Bartholet wants to see a radical transformation in homeschooling. In an article in the Arizona Law Review, “Homeschooling: Parent Rights Absolutism vs. Child Rights to Education & Protection,” she argues that the lack of regulation in the homeschooling system poses a threat to children and society. The Gazette sat down with Bartholet, the Morris Wasserstein Public Interest Professor of Law and faculty director of the Child Advocacy Program at Harvard Law School (HLS), to talk about the problems.”
BARTHOLET: “One is the danger of child maltreatment, and we have evidence that there is a strong connection between homeschooling and maltreatment, which I describe in my article. Other dangers are that children are simply not learning basic academic skills or learning about the most basic democratic values of our society or getting the kind of exposure to alternative views that enables them to exercise meaningful choice about their future lives. Many homeschooling parents are extreme ideologues, committed to raising their children within their belief systems isolated from any societal influence. Some believe that black people are inferior to white people and others that women should be subject to men and not educated for careers but instead raised to serve their fathers first and then their husbands. The danger is both to these children and to society. The children may not have the chance to choose for themselves whether to exit these ideological communities; society may not have the chance to teach them values important to the larger community, such as tolerance of other people’s views and values.”
(NOTE: Covid lockdowns and “remote learning ” actually made more parents WAKE UP to the horrors in public education and look toward Christian education and homeschooling – YET here the Harvard effort seeks to flip the narrative to say that the problem is that Child Protection Services reports are down after Covid shutdowns and that abuse is likely UP “because of homeschooling”. Easy to see how “Shiny Happy People” feeds in to this narrative .
BARTHOLET: “My article was written and submitted for publication prior to the COVID-19 crisis. When that crisis hit I was totally in support of the orders shutting down schools as obviously schools then presented a serious danger of spreading the virus, and of course I believe that the overwhelming majority of parents are capable of providing at least a minimal education at home without presenting any danger of abuse or neglect. I do think, though, that the present near-universal home education situation is illuminating. The evidence is growing that reports to Child Protective Services (CPS) have plummeted nationwide, because children are removed from the mandated reporters that schools provide. “
SCHOOL VOUCHERS ARE ALSO IMPACTING THE ISSUE AS PRIVATE SCHOOLS AND HOMESCHOOLING ARE TARGETED FOR GOVERNMENT FUNDING.
(EXCERPT BY ALEX NEWMAN ON HOW THE FUNDING /VOUCHERS ARE INTENTIONALLY PLANNED AND BEING USED TO BRING ABOUT COMPLIANCE AND MANDATES FROM GOVERNMENTS IN PRIVATE AND CHRISTIAN EDUCATION GLOBALLY)
UNESCO Strategy
“This strategy is actually laid out — not in those words, but nonetheless with remarkable clarity — in a recent Global Education Monitor report commissioned by the UN Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO). According to the report, governments should use tax subsidies for private schools to bring them
under government control and impose regulations mandating “equity” and other goals.
This can be done by forcing entities taking public funds to use certain standards and enforce “centralization and control of the school choice and admissions procedures.” Perhaps even more alarming, under the banner of “autonomy, evaluation, and accountability,” the report proposes “integration of private subsidized schools
into the monitoring and evaluation framework in place for the public sector.”
TRUMP AND EVANGELICALS HAVE NEVER BEEN “A MARRIAGE MADE IN HEAVEN “
Some Reality Checks agains the “Christian Nationalist” Honeytrap.
Most Christians who vote conservative BIBLICAL convictions do vote on the Pro Life issue stance of their candidates and the Republican Party has been the Pro-Life/Anti-Abortion party since the Reagan era. President Donald Trump was THE MOST active President in history for the Pro -Life movement in modern times. Unlike many of the RINO establishment,Trump did not disapoint his followers on this issue and many of those followers were/are Evangelicals. (Trump was and is way too compromised with the LGBTQ lobby for most pro- life- pro- family evangelicals. Some feel he may have lost the 2020 election related battles in part because of this compromise. )
The hard fact is that most evangelical Christian conservatives did not vote to endorse all of Trumps views or his personal history or his business/ celebrity status .They voted for the best candidate to get something actually to change and to prevent Hillary Clinton from being President in 2016 and Joe Biden in 2020. BUT that is not the spin the media- especially most Christian Media operatives like Russell Moore, David French, Marvin Olasky, Albert Mohler,Tim Keller and others have placed on the backs and heads of Christian voters.
THIS IS ALL “REALITY MEDIA ” AND IT IS EVEN MORE FAKE THAN “REALITY TV.”
TRUE CHRISTIANS DO NOT HATE JEWISH PEOPLE, WOMEN WHO HAVE ABORTIONS, OR MINORITES, BECAUSE “REAL CHRISTIANS” HAVE ALWAYS BEEN THE HATED MINORITY AND ARE CALLED TO “LOVE (EVEN) OUR ENEMIES”.
There is a rising lack of support for the Jewish community and for Israel among SOME Christians and much of this is due to the ever warping eschatology of the same influencers involved in the derailment of American conservative seminaries. Non biblical views of the end times and the failure to clarify the call for the Christian witness to spread to the ends of the earth by the Preaching of the Gospel have brought about the substitution of NGO’s, saving the Planet , “redeeming of culture ” and “Community Development ” as the core “vision” of the new evangelicals.This is especially true of those who self- identify as social justice warriors, Neo-Calvinist, and “Civilitas” (third way) Christians. In other words- the church leaders working for/in the other team serving Global Goals, globalism and Faith -Based Partnerships.
These are the Hirelings Jesus talked about in John 10- SEE Bottom.
FOOLS PLAYING THE STRAW MAN
TAKE A LOOK AT THE “END ABORTION NOW” EAN MOVEMENT:
If you watched images of pro-lifers at the SBC annual meetings or from your local State Capitol recently then you might have noticed a movement of radical groups pressing for the prosecution of women who have abortions for murder. They carry the ever ineffective and horrific posters of dead babies ( this is real- not an Alice Cooper stage show) and aborted fetal remains and appear to love to get in the faces of anyone who slows to pass or dares to stop and listen. One such group is led by an aging Calvinist Apologetics named James White and his church teams lead pastor Jeff Durbin of Apologia Church from Phonenix, Arizona. Durbin is a martial arts expert who loves the spotlight and worked as a stunt dubble for the Ninja Turtles brand and in the Mortal Combat franchise. Durbin has found a new home for his celebrity aspirations as a pastor/ activist in the Neo-Hyper Calvinist / cigar smoking/ beer drinking/ tattooed fringe of the evangelical and Calvinist hard right. James White joined the cast of characters on the Apologia Church staff and merged his following with Durbin’s.
The “End Abortion Now” movement has possibly gotten some big funding behind it but that is speculation based on its sudden presence at the SBC annuals and wide spread presence accross the country to State Capitols.
The EAN movements answer is NOT to go for the abortion industry, its multi-billion $$$ funding or planned parenthood or even the Democratic Party or the global Malthusian machine. But EAN chooses rather to go after Women who believe the lies of the machine and end the lives of their own young. Horrific – sinful- Answerable to God YES- But how to end abortion now? or -How the Church should find its redemptive place in the issue?
NO NEVER NOT EVER.
The Durbin narratives also go after Pro -Life activists who are unwilling to embrace this approach and vilify them as not truly pro-life and in lock step with the Abortion Industry . So if you do not want to put women who have abortions on trial for Murder then “you are them… the pro-abortion enemy of “Ending Abortion Now”.
The NY Times picked up the extremism of Durbin and White/Apologia Church views and movement in July of 2022.
Inside the Extreme Effort to Punish Women for Abortion
“Abortion Abolitionists” are the outer edge of the anti-abortion movement. They’re looking to gain followers after the decision to overturn Roe, unsettling mainstream anti-abortion groups.”
BIBLICAL WARNING ALERT – The problem that leaps out off the narrative of prosecuting women who have abortions for murder takes us straight back to the problem in JOHN 8 AND THE WOMAN “CAUGHT IN ADULTERY”. The men of the city cast her at Jesus feet demanding that He pronounce Old Testament judgement ..the DEATH PENALTY…STONING HER …with this “woman caught in the very act…of adultery”. So where was THE MAN ? … And why are these “Abortion Abolitionists ” of “End Abortion Now” heavy hitters giving the fathers of the aborted children a pass on MURDER?
Instead Jesus is reminding these blood thirsty guys that He is seeking and willing to show mercy and that MERCY is based – enabled by His pending sacrifice and with the reminder to “let him who is without sin cast the first stone”. Jesus, after the stones dropped to the ground- turned to this guilty woman and asked “where are your accusers? Does no man condemn you? She replied “No man Lord”. Jesus said “neither do I condemn you, “GO and SIN NO MORE”. This is the Gospel Durbin and his cohorts in EBN look to have lost the gospel in their narrative and forgotten the role of pastors and the saints is the Gospel, NOT the nuancing of pro-life approach. Stop the genocidal Malthusians and eugenics globalist and the billions that flood the global abortion industry annually.That would be the only way to End Abortion Now.
ANTI-ABORTION HYPER CALVINISM -THE SELF CONTRADICTION IS TOO GREAT.
NOTE IT IS INTERESTING TO CONSIDER THE EXTREMES REPRESENTED AMONG THESE TWO GROUPS- THE DUGGARS WITH 19 CHILDREN AND THE DURBINS OF THE NEO-HYPER-CALVINIST REVIVAL. HYPER CALVINIST ARE KNOWN HISTORICALLY FOR SAYING NON-ELECT BABIES ARE CREATED BY GOD TO FUEL THE FIRES OF HELL. ABORTED BABIES , BY THIS NEO-HYPER -CALVINIST THEOLOGY- WOULD BE ORDAINED BY A SOVEREIGN GOD NOT TO BE BORN BUT GIVEN A FAST TRACK TO THEIR NON- ELECT FATES. SO WHY PROSECUTE THE MOTHERS WHO DID GOD’S WILL BY THIS CONFUSED THEOLOGICAL MINDSET?
DURBIN IS OUT DUGGARING THE DUGGARS TO EMBODY THE LEFT’S STRAW MAN.
Christians have to ask -“where is the real Jesus and true Gospel redemption in the media monster mash of would be spokesmen and cultural champions in the Reality Media Narratives?”. Be it the Duggar Parents or Bill Gothard -guru of Homeschoolers or Jeff Durbin and the aging apologist James White – Christians who love the spotlight as celebrity preachers, moral standard bearers and positions as self appointed spokemen for “all True Christian Believers” make themselves vulnerable to becoming “Five Easy Pieces” in the mainstream vilification of REAL Christians. WE are OUR own STRAWMEN AND our own WORST ENEMY .
WHERE IS THIS HEADING ?
All of the talking points that the church is filled with white privileged haters of ethinic groups and ABUSERS OF WOMEN is Broad -Brushed by feminists with their own designs on the church. Is there a problem? Have there been coverups? Are there some people in Christian churches and even leadership who hate and abuse… ? Zero doubt that abuse has taken place but are All Homeschoolers abusers – breeding and indoctrinating future Christian Nationalists? No -ABSOLUTIELY NOT . Are there some? YES just like any other group or institution of every religious or political persuasion . BUT broad-brush tactics and manipulative narratives do not come from people or entities who love the truth and are seeking to help you know it. Secular media have their own ideals to promote and agenda against Biblically conservative Christians.
TRUTH SEEKERS DO NOT NEED CRITICAL THEORIES TO HELP IDENTIFY, SPEAK OR LEAD PEOPLE INTO TRUTH.
THE LEFT LOVES TO VILIFY CHRISTIANS BUT NOT AS MUCH AS THE WELL PLACED PROFESSIONAL “SHAMMERS” FROM WITHIN THE CHURCH AND CHRISTIAN MEDIA.
CONCLUSION
None of these media theatrics in “Reality TV” and “Reality Media ” are REAL. They are agenda driven with those waiting in the wings who have something to gain and seek occasion to turn public opinion against Christians. There is plenty of fault and failure in the church and especially by Christian leaders BUT those targeting Homeschooling want to force government oversight and compliance with perverse and unchristian National Standards and revise history and further the general dumbing down of Americas children already taking place in public education. The same forces seek to shame and reshape Christian voting patterns away from biblical issues like pro-life and towards embrace of abortion “rights”. It is manipulation and DEATH by NARRATIVE. BEST TO IGNORE them and do your own thinking- parenting- voting and continue to follow the Lamb wherever He leads..
Jesus the Good Shepherd
JOHN 10 :7 Then Jesus said to them again, “Most assuredly, I say to you, I am the door of the sheep. 8 All who ever came [a]before Me are thieves and robbers, but the sheep did not hear them. 9 I am the door. If anyone enters by Me, he will be saved, and will go in and out and find pasture. 10 The thief does not come except to steal, and to kill, and to destroy. I have come that they may have life, and that they may have it more abundantly.
11 “I am the good shepherd. The good shepherd gives His life for the sheep. 12 But a hireling, he who is not the shepherd, one who does not own the sheep, sees the wolf coming and leaves the sheep and flees; and the wolf catches the sheep and scatters them. 13 The hireling flees because he is a hireling and does not care about the sheep. 14 I am the good shepherd; and I know My sheep, and am known by My own. 15 As the Father knows Me, even so I know the Father; and I lay down My life for the sheep. 16 And other sheep I have which are not of this fold; them also I must bring, and they will hear My voice; and there will be one flock and one shepherd.
17 “Therefore My Father loves Me, because I lay down My life that I may take it again. 18 No one takes it from Me, but I lay it down of Myself. I have power to lay it down, and I have power to take it again. This command I have received from My Father.”